The changing face of Member Trustees
We take member representation for granted, but it was not always like that. Most trustee boards in the 1970s and 80’s were dominated by the employer’s senior management, and while some schemes appointed member trustees, most did not. A pamphlet, Pension Scheme Trusteeship, published by the NAPF in November 1975, illustrates the point. Rightly, if a little pompously, it concluded that “greater representation should have as its aim a growing awareness of the many problems involved and an improved understanding between employees generally and management. Such harmony is unlikely to derive from an ill-informed or uneducated approach to the role of trusteeship.”
Statutory intervention came in the cautious reforms enacted in the Pensions Act 1995 which followed the Maxwell scandal. So, while a statutory framework was introduced under which schemes were required to appoint a minimum of one third member trustees, the Act allowed employers to opt out of prescribed requirements if a different approach to member representation was endorsed by members.
The attempt to build in flexibility rather than a ‘one size fits all’ approach did not last. By 2004 the mood had changed in favour of greater prescription. The Pensions Act in that year removed the opt out option for employers; for those trustees who felt they needed more guidance a draft Code of Practice on the subject was issued by the Pensions Regulator the following year.
Little chance of an ill-informed or uneducated trustee these days, member nominated or not!
Pensions Archive Trust Director, Jane Marshall
This article was first published in the November 2026 edition of Pensions Age magazine